Know the absolute risk reduction of the covid-19 vaccines!
Vaccine efficacy is another name for relative risk reduction (RRR). The relative risk (RR) ratio of attack rates with and without the vaccine. It is used in vaccine research to compare results between vaccine trials.
The absolute risk reduction of the covid-19 Vaccines are:
• Pfizer-BioNTech – 0.84%
• Moderna – 1.2%
• Gamaleya (Sputnik) – 0.93%
• J&J – 1.2%
• AstraZeneca – 1.3%
Intrigued? Read on.
The vaccine efficacy of covid-19 shots is claimed to be:
• Pfizer-BioNTech 95%
• Moderna 90%
• Gamaleya (Sputnik) 90%
• J&J 67%
• AstraZeneca 67%.
RRR sounds impressive because of the high numbers, which is why it is used in press releases to disseminate news agencies. Medical representatives also tell physicians these numbers. But if RRR is presented alone, it introduces a reporting bias, and RRR only means half of the story.
The FDA requires that RRR be reported together with the absolute risk reduction (ARR). That’s because the ARR is more relevant to the person getting the vaccine. The ARR is the difference between attack rates with and without a vaccine and considers the whole population. ARR tells us about the effectiveness of that vaccine-related to an individual.
Let’s unpack these RRR and ARR. The following is from Outcome Reporting Bias in covid-19 mRNA Vaccine Clinical Trials published in Medicina.
For the covid vaccines, the Relative Risk ratio is the number of people who got covid-19 in the Experimental group over the Placebo or Control group. See figure below.
From: Outcome Reporting Bias in covid-19 mRNA Vaccine Clinical Trials.
In the figure above, the number of people who got covid among the 100 vaccinated is, or Experimental event rate (EER) is 1/100 or one percent.
The Control group on the right side did not get the vaccine. Among them, two people got covid-19. The Control Event Rate (CER) is 2/100 or two percent.
The Relative Risk Reduction (RRR) or Vaccine reduction relative to placebo risk formula is ARR (0.01)/CER (0.02) = RRR 0.5 (50%).
The formula for the absolute risk reduction (ARR) or vaccine risk reduction is
CER 0.02 (2%) – EER 0.01(1%) = ARR 0.01 (one percent).
ARR for this example means that the vaccine reduced the risk of getting the disease by only one percent.
Now that we know how the RRR and ARR are derived…
What is the absolute risk reduction of the current covid-19 vaccines?
• Pfizer-BioNTech – 0.84%
• Moderna – 1.2%
• Gamaleya (Sputnik) – 0.93%
• J&J – 1.2%
• AstraZeneca – 1.3%.
They’r pretty low, aren’t they? But wait, there’s more!
Number needed to vaccinate
The ARR can be used to calculate the number needed to vaccinate (NNV). NNV is answering the question how many people need to be vaccinated to prevent one case of Covid-19? The ideal answer should be one.
The formula is NNV = 1/ARR. So, the numbers willl be:
• Pfizer-BioNTech – 117
• Moderna – 76
• Gamaleya (Sputnik) – 80
• J&J – 84
• AstraZeneca – 78
The Pfizer NNV number means that only one will benefit among 117 people vaccinated with the Pfizer-BioNTech BNT162b2 mRNA vaccine. The rest may still get Covid-19.
If you only know Pfizer’s numbers, the relative risk, you will think that the NNV is close to one since it is 95 percent vaccine efficacy! But that 95% RRR relates only to the vaccine trial and not to the person who will get the vaccine. That’s why it is essential to know the ARR and NNV.
The numbers presented are study numbers. What about the actual numbers since the vaccination campaign started?
An exemple is the Israeli mass vaccination, using the Pfizer-Biontech shots: the RRR was 94%, similar to the phase 3 trial (95%). However, the ARR is only 0.46%, with an NNV of 217. The ARR is much lower than the Pfizer study showed, and the NNV is 1.8 times higher.
Parting thoughts
We are awash in propaganda from the particular interest that makes billions from the vaccination. Knowing absolute risk reduction is a valuable tool that anyone can use to weigh the risks and benefits of getting an FDA-unapproved vaccine.
Knowledge about covid-19 is rapidly evolving, and information may update as new studies are made.
Don’t get sick!
yogaesoteric
July 28, 2022